Neither choice is wrong, and neither is as extreme as its critics claim. Cloth isn't the constant boiling-and-scrubbing chore it was decades ago, and disposables aren't a single monolithic product — eco-friendly disposable lines exist specifically for parents who want the convenience without the full environmental footprint. Here's what actually differs, not the caricature of each side.
Disposables cost more over time — a rough estimate is $70-$100+ per month per baby, adding up to $2,000-$3,000+ before potty training. Cloth has a higher upfront cost (a starter set of modern all-in-one or pocket diapers typically runs $300-$600) but a much lower ongoing cost — mainly water, detergent, and electricity for washing, plus the diapers themselves can often be reused for a second child. The breakeven point is usually somewhere in the first year, depending on how much washing you do yourself vs. use a diaper laundering service (which narrows the cost gap but is more convenient).
This is the tradeoff people underestimate in both directions. Modern cloth diapers snap or velcro like a disposable — you're not folding and pinning anything — but you are doing an extra load of laundry every 2-3 days, and dealing with a wet bag when you're out. Disposables win clearly on convenience, especially for overnight (higher absorbency options exist specifically for longer stretches) and for travel or daycare, where cloth can be logistically harder depending on the provider's policy.
Disposables are a genuine landfill contributor — a baby will go through roughly 2,000-3,000 diapers before potty training, none of which biodegrade quickly. Cloth avoids that waste stream but has its own footprint from water and energy use in washing, which is real but generally smaller, especially with a full-load, energy-efficient laundry routine. If full-time cloth isn't realistic for your situation, eco-conscious disposable brands (using plant-based materials, chlorine-free processing) are a genuine middle ground — not a marketing gimmick, but not equivalent to cloth's footprint either.
Disposable: newborn size and size 1 to start (babies outgrow newborn size faster than expected — don't over-buy it), fragrance-free wipes, and a diaper pail. Cloth: a starter set in a one-size or newborn-specific system (check which — many "one-size" cloth diapers don't actually fit well until around 8-10 lbs, so a small newborn-specific set bridges the gap), a wet bag or two, cloth-safe diaper cream (zinc oxide barrier creams can coat and reduce absorbency in cloth, so cloth-specific or coconut-oil-based options are worth registering for separately), and if you're not washing yourself, research diaper service availability in your area before committing.
Plenty of families do cloth at home and disposable for daycare, travel, or the overnight stretch when absorbency matters most. Starting with a small cloth trial set rather than a full supply is a low-risk way to find out whether the routine actually fits your household before committing further.
Whichever way you lean, we'll build the diapering section of your registry around it — cloth, disposable, or a mix of both.
Build My Nest